Hiccup x Reader: Expect the Unexpected[chapter 3]

You sat there peacefully beside Toothless and Hiccup and watched as they slept in peace. Hiccup mumbling from time to time. You watched as the sun set on the horizon.

"Are they really that tired? They've been sleeping, like for hours " You say as you stare at them. Then you hear low roars from above, you tilted your head upright to see Astrid,once again, on a bluish dragon with huge spikes. You watched her as she climbed down the dragon and stomped off toward you, anger evident in her eyes.

"what did YOU do to them?" She pointed an accusing finger at you then at the rider and dragon.

"I didn't do anything to them. Why are you angry at me? I never did anything to you to make you angry at me! Heck, I don't even know you!" You shrieked slightly offended, hands balled into fists.

"Oh really ? are you sure you never did anything to make me feel like this?" she pointed at herself. You shrugged your shoulders still staring at her angrily.

"Hiccup and I share something you could never take away from us . We LOVE each other. Yes I said it. The most dreaded word in all viking existence." Astrid then walked closer to you clenching her fists in your face.

"If I see even a strand of hair missing, you'll be getting it." She said as she stomped back to her dragon. You sighed deeply as you sat back down beside Hiccup.

"Why do I mess everyone's lives up?"

"Hiccup and I share something you could never take away from us . We LOVE each other. Yes I said it. The most dreaded word in all viking existence." Astrid's words kept ringing in your head.

You stared quietly at Hiccup. He looked so peaceful that way...

You stood up and brushed the sand off you and wandered off, away from the two dreamers. You think deeply as you walked through the island you noticed that it's been getting dark so you ran off to Hiccup and Toothless. On your way you hear a growl that sounded deep and raspy, almost like it was a dragon's.

"Hiccup? I-is that you?" You approached the source nervously, from behind you feel as though you were thrown into a sack.

"Hey, let me go!" You squirmed from inside the sack and you hit a person when you kicked.

"Ow." It was a voice you never heard of.

"This girl, she knows the boy. She must be of value to him. We'll take her to the island before Alvin gets angry." You feel yourself being placed on a boat. You see a hole on the sack and quickly tore it until you could see what was going on. From the other end of the beach you see Hiccup and Toothless , stretching and saying something inaudible.

"Hiccup... help me, please ." You pleaded under your breath as you wiped a tear off your cheek.

Meanwhile...

Hiccup opened his eyes slowly, yawning and nudged at Toothless to wake up. He looks around and finds you missing.

"Hey Toothless, you've seen [name]?" He asks the dragon, the dragon shook his head and nudged his rider to go back home.

"But we can't just leave without her. Come on, let's look around." He continued searching for a while . He considered this case hopeless. Since Toothless could see and smell better , Toothless spotted something with the same scent as yours. Upon discovering the item he quickly searched for Hiccup and lead him the item. it was your [accessory].

"I need to find her. Toothless fly me back to the dragon academy, now." He ordered the beast in a strict tone and guided Toothless to fly out on the open sky . Hiccup reached the academy faster than he expected. Seeing no sign of you anywhere, Astrid was temporarily in a good mood.

"hey, Hiccup we got worried something happened to you. You didn't show up this morning." Astrid said cheerfully unaware of what was going on, on Hiccup's mind. Hiccup clearly paid no attention as he just waltz past her.

"snotlout, Fishlegs I need you two to come with me. Astrid , Ruff, Tuff I need you three to take care of the academy while we're away. Let's go, I'll explain it to you on the way." The tree quickly got on their dragons without another word spoken.

"Ignored." Ruff taunted the blonde viking which was of course returned with an angry glare.

----------------------------------------

"Why exactly are we in the middle of nowhere?" Snotlout asked as they were high up in the sky.

"Yeah, why ARE we here?" Fishlegs said as he ducked because birds almost hit him on the face.

Where you were at...

One of the men opened the sack and you see yourself in an unknown island. It was the complete opposite of peaceful. Everywhere dragons were shooting fire at houses causing it to burst into flames.

"I am Alvin, and welcome to outcast island."

"what do you want from me?" You glared at the big man in the middle who seems to call himself Alvin.

"I need to know if you know something of a certain boy, who has trained the most dangerous dragon of all. The night fury " His voice was filled with anger as he said those last words. You gulped loudly.

"I can't tell him... If I do then Hiccup'll get into trouble, I can't risk his life..." You were thinking hard for an excuze before the man suddenly gripped your neck tightly lifting you up to his eye level. You gag as he lifts you higher.

"If you don't tell the truth I might as well cage you with the other dragons " You couldn't reply, and even if you could, you still wouldn't.

"Not talking eh?" He drops you to the ground and you begin taking huge breaths of air.

"tie 'er up and cage her with the lot." The big gruff man said as he climbed aboard the ship . You were dragged to a place under an arena. An arena used to keep dragons tied up. "Sick. Hiccup would never do those things to dragons."

You were brought underground where most of the prisoner were, you knew in an instant that Alvin was a heartless person, he even had an elder imprisoned. "Pleasant dreams." One of the men said as he locked your cell door. All you could do at the moment was curl up in a corner and hope for someone, anyone, to help you.

Meanwhile...

Hiccup, snotlout and Fishlegs have been searching for hours.

"Ugh, we've been searching here for hours let's just call this a day." snotlout cried out in exasperation.

"But-"

"Hiccup, it's getting dark the chief won't be happy if he finds out we're out til night." Fishlegs reasoned cutting Hiccup off mid-sentence.

"Fine..." Hiccup agreed and they turn their dragons around and fly back to Berk. Upon reaching Berk they find Astrid, Ruff and Tuff on their dragons and his father on Astrid's.

"what's going on around here?" Hiccup asked his dad as he flew toward him. Toothless growled as he neared the cliff.

"Be quiet. Outcasts have infiltrated the island, they're looking for you." Then at that right moment they hear a voice.

"Oh Hiccup, I have something for you. I have a pretty little girl on Outcast island. Maybe I should get rid of her, she is of no use to me anyway. " The man said in sing-song voice.

"Alvin. H-he's..." He flew back out heading for outcast island.

"Your mine now, Hiccup. Men, back to the boats." Alvin barked at the men that are goofing about.

"Hold on [name] I'm almost there. Faster bud." He pet the dragon's head and shot off. They reach outcast island and there they see a whole fleet of outcast ships all armed with catapults.

The poor dragon tried to blast off some and evade the huge rocks that was thrown. It became a whole lot harder when Alvin's ships, that had returned from Berk, decided to join the fight. Toothless sent out an anguished cry as one of the boulders hit him sending both of them to one of Alvin's boat. Hiccup had tried to hit the men but he was no match for their big beefy arms and hard metal armor.

"Ah nice of you to visit us dear little Hiccup. And when I say little I mean LITTLE." The whole lot of them snickered.

"Do what you want but just don't hurt [name]." hiccup reasoned.

"Ah yes, the whole 'sacrifice' thing." Hiccup was tied up and was led to the your dungeon cell. You were asleep so Hiccup assumed they did something to you.

"Let 'im in before we take 'er back to Berk's shore." Hiccup was thrown in creating a loud creaking noise as the cell gates opened. You awoke to the sudden noise.

"[name]. Are you ok?" Hiccup wanted to comfort you by hugging you tightly in his arms but the chains didn't allow him to.

"I-I'm fine." You manage to say between sobs.

"They did something to you didn't they?" You remained silent "Why didn't you just tell them that you knew me? Then I would be the one experiencing the pain instead of you."

"That's exactly the point why I didn't want to. I don't want you getting hurt." You admit sobbing on his shoulders.

"Why... Why would you risk your life for someone you don't even know?" was the only thing Hiccup could say, You open your eyes slowly and looked into his eyes.

"B-Because... well you could say that I..." You mumbled.

"That you what?" Hiccup demanded.

"THAT I LOVE THIS STRANGER. That I love this stranger that is with me right now. Even though I don't really know what you and Astrid shared I'll still say that I love this stranger!" You continued to sob on his shoulder.

"I can't take anymore of this love fest! Take the girl so that we can leave immediately." Alvin barked at a crying outcast beside him.

"But Alvin it's too cruel." The outcast sniffed.

"Oh dear Thor I'll do it myself " Alvin snatched the keys and went inside, he already had in mind of dragging you out only to make Hiccup feel horrible, but you stood up , sniffed and walked over to Alvin.

"[name]..." Hiccup stared at you as you walked quietly.

"let's get 'er back." You were brought to a large ship and when you neared the shore they let you down.

Of all the people who could have seen you with an outcast ship it just so happens that Astrid found you when she was returning from flying with Stormfly. The outcast ship sailed off.

"I better do something about this chain. And find someone to help Hiccup..." You sighed trying to forget what had just happened with Hiccup. 

"You, where is Hiccup?" You turned around, and was faced by an angry-looking Astrid. A club in her hand.

"I knew it. what did you do to Hiccup?" Astrid demanded as she shook you hard.